DC Resistance Unbalance: Was Sie wissen müssen

An Essential Parameter for PoE Performance

Power over Ethernet (PoE) has revolutionized device connectivity, but its success hinges on maintaining signal integrity. Since the early days of 2-pair 802.3af and 802.3at PoE, the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) has specified limits on DC resistance unbalance between conductors within twisted pair cables to prevent interference with Ethernet data. The introduction of higher-power 802.3bt (Type 3 and 4) PoE, which utilizes all four cable pairs, further emphasized the importance of DC resistance unbalance, adding requirements for testing between pairs.

While DC resistance unbalance has not traditionally been specified in industry cabling and standards, Fluke Networks has long recognized it as an essential performance parameter for reliable PoE performance. That is why our DSX CableAnalyzer™ copper cable certification tester has supported field testing DC resistance unbalance since the IEEE first specified it back in 2014. That is also why we consistently recommended it for PoE assurance.

What Is DC Resistance Unbalance?

PoE power transmits over pairs as a common-mode voltage that gets split equally between conductors in a pair and between each pair. The DC resistance of both conductors in a pair and the DC resistance of each pair must be balanced for this to happen.

When there is a difference in DC resistance between conductors and pairs, it is called DC resistance unbalance. In PoE systems that deliver power simultaneously with data, too much DC resistance unbalance between conductors and pairs can saturate a device's transformer. The result is distorted Ethernet data signals that can cause bit errors, retransmits, and non-functioning links.

Was verursacht eine DC-Widerstand-Unsymmetrie?

Several factors can contribute to DC resistance unbalance in cabling systems. While internal transformer issues in PoE devices can be a cause, too much DC resistance unbalance is more frequently attributed to installation practices and cable quality. Exceeding the minimum bend radius of a cable, failing to maintain pair twists close to the termination point, and inconsistent or poor quality terminations can increase DC resistance unbalance. A 4-pair punch-down termination tool that terminates all 8 conductors simultaneously with equal force can help ensure consistent terminations.

Subpar cable quality can also be a culprit for DC resistance imbalance. Variations in conductor diameter, concentricity (roundness), contour, or smoothness create a higher risk for DC resistance unbalance. Additionally, non-compliant cables containing copper-clad aluminum (CCA), copper-coated steel, or other non-standard conductors that are not 100% copper exhibit higher DC resistance and DC resistance unbalance due to their inherent inconsistencies.

What Is the Maximum Allowed DC Resistance Unbalance?

DC resistance unbalance testing qualifies the difference in resistance between conductors within a pair and between pairs. Ideally, this value would be zero, indicating perfectly matched resistances. However, practical factors like variations in pair twists and termination quality inevitably introduce some degree of unbalance. While devices can tolerate a certain level, the imposed limits ensure proper performance.

In line with IEEE standards, the TIA-568 standard specifies the maximum allowed DC resistance unbalance between conductors within each pair as 3% of the pair's total DC loop resistance or 0,20 Ω. The standard specifies a maximum of 7% or 0,20 Ω for DC resistance unbalance between pairs.

How Is DC Resistance Unbalance Tested?

The Fluke Networks DSX CableAnalyzer™ certification tester was the first to support field testing for DC resistance unbalance as a critical measurement for ensuring that a cabling plant can adequately support PoE. Before we introduced this capability — more than a decade before it was specified in TIA-568.2 — DC resistance unbalance could only be conducted as a laboratory measurement, since no field tester could test for it.

The DSX CableAnalyzer tester automatically displays DC resistance unbalance, both within a pair and between pairs, with its default (+PoE) test limit. The tester determines the DC resistance unbalance within a pair, measures the DC resistance on each conductor, calculates the difference, and compares it to the total DC loop resistance of the pair (sum of both conductors) as shown below.

^{The DC resistance is measured on each conductor. The DC loop resistance is the sum of both conductors and the DC resistance unbalance is the difference (1,87 Ω - 1,85 Ω).}

For DC resistance unbalance between pairs, the DSX CableAnalyzer tester measures the resistance on each conductor of a pair, calculates the parallel resistance for each pair, and then compares the parallel resistance of each pair to all other pairs as shown below for pairs 1,2 and 3,6.

^{The parallel resistance for pairs 1,2 and 3,6 is calculated by measuring the resistance for each conductor of the pair. The DC resistance unbalance between pairs 1,2 and 3,6 is 0,11 Ω, which is the difference in parallel resistance between the pairs (0,33 Ω – 0,22  Ω).}

The DSX CableAnalyzer tester displays PASS or FAIL for DC loop resistance and DC resistance unbalance within a pair (PAIR UBL) and between pairs (P2P UBL). Note that DC resistance unbalance between pairs must take into account DC resistance unbalance within each pair to achieve a PASS.

^{DC loop resistance and DC resistance unbalance between pairs fail if DC resistance unbalance within a pair fails.}

Do I Have to Test for DC Resistance Unbalance?

With TIA-568 standards now specifying DC resistance unbalance, there has been a misconception that it is now required for field testing. Technically, it is not required by industry standards — but that doesn't mean you shouldn't do it. It also doesn't necessarily mean you don't have to do it.

ANSI/TIA-568.2 now specifies values for calculating DC resistance unbalance for each pair and between pairs, but these standards do not specify field testing requirements. Those requirements can be found in ANSI/TIA-1152 Requirements for Field Test Instruments and Measurements for Balanced Twisted Pair Cabling. While it remains to be seen if the next version of the TIA-1152 standard will add it, the standard does not currently specify DC resistance unbalance as a field testing requirement.

Field testing for DC resistance unbalance is highly recommended. But in reality, it doesn't matter what the standards say or what Fluke Networks or PoE experts recommend — if your customer specifies DC resistance unbalance testing, you must do it. If your customer requires a warranty on the cabling plant, and your cabling manufacturer requires DC resistance unbalance testing to get that warranty, you must do it. This is no different than any other performance parameter. If your customer or manufacturer specifies alien crosstalk testing, for example, you must do it. That's why it's essential to communicate with your customer and cabling manufacturer to agree on what tests they require per the project specification and to receive a cabling system warranty.

How Long Does It Take to Test DC Resistance Unbalance?

In addition to confusion about whether DC resistance unbalance field testing is required, there exist some misconceptions about how long it takes to test for it.

As the industry's most accurate Level VI/2G certification tester, the DSX CableAnalyzer certifier takes only about 10 seconds for a full permanent link auto test. Testing for DC resistance unbalance by sticking with the tester's default PoE+ test limit adds just 3 seconds, for a total testing time of about 13 seconds. Those extra 3 seconds are well worth it, especially considering they could save you from having to troubleshoot a cabling plant later.

Check out this video with our own application expert Jim Davis to see the testing in action.

We Have Always Had You Covered

For over a decade, Fluke Networks DSX CableAnalyzer certification tester has led the way in field testing of DC resistance unbalance. Now, with the latest TIA-568 standards recognizing this critical parameter, you're already equipped. Our long-standing advocacy for this critical test ensures your cable plants deliver optimal performance for both gigabit Ethernet and high-power PoE, which is particularly crucial for advanced Wi-Fi 6/6E and Wi-Fi 7 access points.

Mehr erfahren

• •  Fluke Networks Copper Certification Testers
• •  White Paper: DC-Widerstand-Unsymmetrietest Einfache, preiswerte Versicherung für Ihre PoE-Systeme
• •  The IoT and LED Lighting: Jetzt ist die Zeit für Balance
• •  Upgrading to Four-Pair PoE: Was Sie wissen müssen
• •  Testing Power Over Ethernet (PoE)